I really wanted to love this shirt. I know OR products are top quality and their guarantee is extraordinary. I've been wary that my body may not be a good fit for OR products. My perfect fit is a classic cut in XL Tall as I'm 6'4" and 255 lbs with 36 inch sleeve. The cut of this shirt was strange. The sleeves were very tight which is odd as my forearms are not beefy like Edgar Martinez in his heyday, nor are there fat and puffy like the Michelin Man.