Cozy, breathable, good looking, practical...what's not to love? This jacket is cut loose for layering (it fits comfortably over my Deadbolt hoody, which is quite a close fit, or a heavy sweater). I find the length works for me, and like that it's shorter in front and longer in back. I'm 5'8" and 145lb with a 29" inseam, for reference. The outer fabric pills. I don't mind, and think it looks lived in rather than worn. Finally, breathability comes at the expense of any wind resistance at all. I think it's a good tradeoff for a much wider usable temperature range. Put a shell on over it, and it's a cozy refuge in the wind and blowing snow.